iTunes

Opening the iTunes Store.If iTunes doesn’t open, click the iTunes application icon in your Dock or on your Windows desktop.Progress Indicator
Opening Apple Books.If Apple Books doesn't open, click the Books app in your Dock.Progress Indicator
iTunes

iTunes is the world's easiest way to organize and add to your digital media collection.

We are unable to find iTunes on your computer. To download and subscribe to Phoebe's Fall by The Age Melbourne, get iTunes now.

Already have iTunes? Click I Have iTunes to open it now.

I Have iTunes Free Download

Phoebe's Fall

By The Age Melbourne

To listen to an audio podcast, mouse over the title and click Play. Open iTunes to download and subscribe to podcasts.

Description

A major investigation by The Age newsroom in Melbourne, Australia, into the death of Phoebe Handsjuk, who was found at the bottom of a garbage chute in a luxury apartment building.

Customer Reviews

Poor mans version of Serial

I appreciate what the podcast is trying to do, but unlike 'Serial' the reporters are obviously biased and discount evidence that they don't think is relevant. This removes the ability for the listener to judge evidence for themselves and highlights a bigger problem in Australian journalism where a reporters opinion is seen more important than fact. It is also unfortunate that their narrating ability is poor, they are not naturals at the microphone. All in all I would skip this. There is nothing of interest in how they present the story and I can only assume that their friends and colleagues are the ones giving the high star rating. Disappointing.

Not happy

The 'investigation' involved in this podcast is totally second rate.
I came to this podcast looking forward to a genuine mystery, similar to those presented by the excellent 'True Crime Garage'.

Instead, what I find are just a series of 'suspicions' from the victim's friends and family (I sympathise with their grief, but the podcast producers should not have given them airtime in support of their 'mystery'). Suspicions are NOT EVIDENCE.

Beyond these assumptions, there is simply no credible evidence that Ant Hampel or anyone else was involved in Phoebe's death, and yet he is implicitly accused of committing this crime. The Coroner's findings are dismissed on the basis of some inconclusive experiments relating to the difficulty of someone climbing into the chute. And yet the overwhelming evidence of the day in question is that Hampel could not possibly have been involved in her death. His whereabouts were fully accounted for during the day. He arrived home at 6pm and she was found at 7pm. However, he was occupied making phone calls during the period 6-7 pm, and this is fully documented. Not to mention that Phoebe had clearly not died precisely at 7pm, but at some time prior.

One other point - the video test of someone placing another person in the chute, shows the victim not resisting. If the person was conscious, they would be resisting and I suggest it would be impossible to place them feet first into the chute (unless it was an assisted suicide!!). So the only possible scenario would be that she was unconscious. OK lets look at that. So someone carried her unconscious through the building to the 12 floor chute. Really? I don't think so.

The 'secret tape' was evidence of nothing. Totally worthless, and yet it was the title of an episode!.

There is no credible evidence that Ant Hampel's behaviour after the death was inappropriate.

Think about it. What they are suggesting is an extreme case of domestic violence. Almost invariably, in these DV cases there is a long history of abuse. And yet here…nothing. And the evidence of Phoebe's psychologist was that she complained about the relationship, but she said nothing about abuse.

It is little surprise that most of the professional protagonists in the case refused to co-operate with this 'investigation'.

There is no 'mystery' here. If I were Ant Hampel I would be suing the socks off The Age, and I hereby volunteer to work on the case.

Okay but nothing on Serial

With all due respect to the story; which is harrowing and yet another showcase of the system failing those who are most vulnerable, the podcast itself is quite amateur in its production and narration.

Phoebe's Fall
View in iTunes

Customer Ratings