As Mr. and Mrs. Stauffer mourn the death of their son, Simon, who died during his rumspringa, Bree Fortsworth knocks on their door and announces she is having Simon's baby. Bree explains she has nowhere else to go and asks if she can stay with them. After they agree to her request she has another and the Stauffers are surprised when Bree wants them to adopt the baby. After Bree has been staying with the Stauffer family for some weeks, Simon's brother Andrew doubts what Bree is telling his parents and confronts her with his suspicions. What will Andrew do when he finds out Bree's secrets? Will Bree's and Mr. and Mrs. Stauffer's plans be thrown into doubt after another unexpected visitor knocks on their door?